Advisory Opinions

Live from the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg Center in Washington, D.C., Sarah Isgur and David French review the OT25 term with Akhil Amar, professor of law and political science at Yale University, and David Lat, author of Original Jurisdiction. The four break down the most consequential cases of the past term—from the tariffs case to Humphrey’s Executor, birthright citizenship, and what it all means...

Sarah Isgur and David French slow things down with an overview of the yearly Stat Pack released by SCOTUSblog, look at the dissents in the birthright citizenship case, and answer listeners’ questions about everything from the 14th Amendment being sex-blind to whether independent agencies could be recreated within the legislative branch. The Agenda:–Stat Pack: Findings–Trump v. Barbara could have...

SCOTUS strikes down a Donald Trump executive order ending birthright citizenship, reshapes campaign finance law, and rules that states can exclude transgender athletes from girls’ and women’s sports teams. Sarah Isgur and David French discuss in a marathon end-of-term episode. The Agenda”–The pre-apology–Trump v. Barbara–Wow, we were wrong–Et tu, Barrett? (No, not really)–What is the purpose of...

Sarah Isgur and David French break down the latest Supreme Court opinions regarding unitary executive theory, mail-in voting, and the Fourth Amendment.The Agenda:—Unitary executive theory gets tested—Dorm-room originalism—Lisa Cook keeps her job—Mail-in voting—Text, history, and ...—Geofence warrantsShow notes:—Trump v. Slaughter—Myers v. United States—Humphrey's Executor v. United States—Sarah...

Sarah Isgur and David French react to the latest opinions of the court in two major immigration cases and a review of Hawaii’s restrictions on concealed-carry permits.The Agenda:—The SCOTUS opinion day “ritual”—Hawaii gun restrictions—Shall not be infringed—Border dispute over asylum seekers—Judicial review of TPS—Trump's “Muslim” banShow notes:—Destiny of the RepublicAdvisory Opinions is a...

Sarah Isgur and David French explain the various legal complications of the Iran MOU and react to the most recent opinions handed down by the Supreme Court.The Agenda:—Waiving Iranian sanctions—Suing state employees personally—International law in U.S. courts—Cuban confiscation case—Seizing homes over unpaid taxes—The rights of green card holdersShow notes:—Jack Goldsmith at Executive Functions...

Sarah Isgur and David French react to two new Supreme Court opinions on gun ownership while possessing illegal drugs and appeal waivers.The Agenda:—Drugs and the Second Amendment—Rewriting Bruen—Bad plea deals—Overcharging crimes—The Gorsuch-Kavanaugh dynamic—The DOJ and the Hyde AmendmentShow notes:—United States v. Hemani—Hunter v. United StatesAdvisory Opinions is a production of The Dispatch,...

Sarah Isgur and David French break down the most recent cert grants out of the Supreme Court's order list and Trump's argument for suspending habeas corpus.The Agenda:—Paid petitions vs. In Forma Pauperis—Six-person juries in Florida—Can undocumented immigrants be held indefinitely?—New York Times reporting on Trump and habeas corpus—Leaked memo fallout—Lawyers using AI—Georgia campaign finance...

Sarah Isgur and David French discuss the three SCOTUS decisions that dropped Thursday morning, a D.C. Circuit decision on President Donald Trump's ban on transgender military members, and accommodations running rampant at law schools. Oh, and a federal judge charged with battery and destruction of physical property. The Agenda:–Sign up for the SCOTUSblog newsletter–We are faced with the duddiest...

Sarah Isgur and David French look at what’s left on the docket from this term before diving into a little Los Angeles mayoral politics. The Agenda:–Supreme Court bingo–Do Rastafarians get religious exemptions?–The mighty small-dollar donor – United States v. Hemani–Wolford v. Lopez–Appearance of election corruption–No, a GOP candidate did not have a chance to become mayor of Los...